Baylake Vacation Rentals Revenue X-Ray
Door County cohosting · Founding Five

Your cottage isn't underperforming.
Its management is.

Baylake Vacation Rentals is a Door County, Wisconsin vacation rental cohosting company run by owner Dana. We run listings, pricing, guests, turnovers and preventive maintenance for a small, capped book of waterfront and near-water homes in southern and central Door County (Sturgeon Bay, Little Sturgeon, Sawyer Harbor, Idlewild and Egg Harbor), mostly for owners who live in Green Bay, Milwaukee, Madison or Chicago.

Before we bought them, the market data projected $40,000 a year for each of our two cottages. That projection wasn't careless — it accurately priced what average management earns in this market. Here's what five seasons of a documented system did to it instead.

Gross booking revenue from our OwnerRez records, including cleaning fees and guest charges. 2026 reflects confirmed bookings as of 16 November 2026, with the holiday weeks still to sell. Sawyer Harbor's 2022 is a partial first year — it launched in June.
Combined, two cottages20222023202420252026
Booked$173,699$184,854$203,118$183,279$211,249
vs. $80,000 projected2.2×2.3×2.5×2.3×2.6×

“2.4×” is the average of the five yearly multiples shown above (2.2×–2.6×), each measured against a combined $80,000 full-year AirDNA projection. Across the same years, combined gross bookings were about $956,000 as of 16 November 2026 (OwnerRez, including cleaning fees and guest charges) against a five-season projection baseline of about $383,000, which counts Sawyer Harbor’s 2022 as a partial first year — roughly 2.5× in total. 2026 is confirmed bookings as of 16 November 2026, with the holiday weeks still to sell. These results are for properties we own and are not a guarantee for any other property.

445
Guest reviews
4.97
Average rating
1.8×
The market's revenue per available night
5
Seasons, no outliers
Rocky Shores Retreat seen from the water at Little Sturgeon, on the Green Bay shore
The gap

Your projection isn't your ceiling. It's a report card on the management the data assumes.

Every Door County rental has a number the industry believes it can earn. Ours was $40,000 each. Most owners never find out that number is an assumption rather than a limit — because nothing in the way the property is run ever tests it.

The difference between average management and excellent management on our two cottages has been about $110,000 a year.

That gap is claimable. The question a Revenue X-Ray answers is how much of it is sitting on your property.

The system

Attention doesn't scale. Written-down work does.

Every manager promises to treat your cottage like their own. We'll concede the part they won't: owner attention is finite, and it runs out at the fourth property, or on one July Saturday with three turnovers and a failed water heater.

What holds the standard is that the work is documented and happens whether or not anyone feels like doing it. That's the whole argument, and it's why the same four disciplines produced the same floor on two properties that share nothing but an operator.

  • Pricing, reviewed weekly

    Repriced against the real comp set — not a seasonal calendar set once in March. The off-peak is where the extra revenue actually lives.

  • Listings rebuilt each micro-season

    Photos, title and copy re-cut for whoever is actually searching that month, from fall color to the holidays.

  • Preventive maintenance on a schedule

    A 266-point inspection run by StayReady. Nothing is broken when a guest walks in, because the failure was found before the stay rather than during it.

  • And when something does break, we fix it

    Not a vendor list and a wait. “Hosts were proactive and super responsive when there was an issue with the air conditioning, and got someone out to fix things very quickly.” — Chrystal M., Rocky Shores Retreat, Aug 2025.

  • Guest experience staged, not improvised

    Stocking, linens and messaging run from a checklist, so the fortieth stay of the season looks like the first.

The Property of One

Your cottage isn't a unit in a portfolio. It's a market of one.

A portfolio manager optimizes across properties. We do the opposite: each home gets its own pricing logic, its own brand, its own booking site and its own guest. Here is that idea on our own two cottages.

Rocky Shores Retreat homepage at rockyshoresretreat.com

Rocky Shores Retreat

Little Sturgeon Bay

  • 3 bedrooms, 1 bath, sleeps 10, bunk house
  • 180 feet of private shoreline, kayaks, wood-burning fireplace
  • Own domain, own direct booking, own guest list

rockyshoresretreat.com

Sawyer Harbor Retreat homepage at sawyerharborretreat.com

Sawyer Harbor Retreat

Sawyer Harbor

  • 2 bedrooms + loft, 2 baths, sleeps 10
  • Private dock, kayaks and a canoe, screened sun porch, gas fireplace
  • Own domain, own direct booking, own guest list

sawyerharborretreat.com

Open both. Read the difference, not the quality — two homes run by one company should not sound like the same house. Guests can also start at baylakevacationrentals.com.

Why the book stays small
5

Five properties this first year.

We visit every property personally, and five is the number we can keep that promise on. It isn't a marketing device — it's the ceiling that makes the standard hold. When the five are placed, the list closes until we can staff past it honestly.

The founding five sign on our Baseline & Upside terms: 15% on what the property already makes, 25% only on what we add, and that baseline fixed for three seasons. We earn more only when you do.

Qualified properties are also covered by a written revenue guarantee. It's underwritten property by property, so the terms are set out in your proposal rather than advertised here — and we only offer it where the analysis shows the gap is real.

Fit

Who this is for

  • Waterfront or near-water Door County homes

    Three bedrooms or more, and realistically capable of $100,000 a year or more.

  • Owners who don't live here

    Green Bay, Milwaukee, Madison, Chicago — far enough that the drive up to meet a contractor costs a day.

  • Owners who want the asset run properly

    Not the cheapest fee. The best five-year outcome for a home you intend to keep.

Not a fit

Who it isn't

  • Anyone shopping purely on percentage

    If the smallest number on a pricing page is the deciding factor, a volume manager will serve you better than we will. Our structure rewards growth, not the lowest rate.

  • Properties that can't clear the gate

    If the analysis doesn't show meaningful upside, we'll tell you and we won't take the property.

  • Owners who want to stay hands-on daily

    The system only works if it's allowed to run.

For owners researching management

Start with the question you actually have.

Door County cohosting

What we run, who it's for, and how the fee works — in one place.

Waterfront management

Why shoreline homes need a different operating standard, from two cottages we own.

How to choose a manager

Self-manage, cohost, or full-service: a plain comparison and the questions worth asking.

New to Wisconsin's rules? Door County short-term rental licenses and room tax, with links to the official sources.

Start here

What's the gap on your property?

We'll visit your cottage — or the one you're considering buying — benchmark it against its true competitive set, and put a number on the gap. Free, and useful whether or not you ever hire anybody.